Your best bird this season. Who's the keeper?
Fall is decision time. Every bird carried through winter is eating feed while laying slows down, so this is when a lot of keepers pick who stays as breeding stock and who doesn’t.
So who earned a spot this year?
- The heaviest bird, the best layer, the calmest one in the cage?
- What are you actually selecting for: size, egg count, egg size, temperament, color?
- Do you pick on one trait at a time or try to balance them?
- How are you keeping track of who’s who: leg bands, separate cages, records?
Tell us about the one bird you’d never let go, and what made that bird the keeper.
Good topic, Ron — this is exactly the kind of thinking that makes a flock better year over year instead of just bigger.
I’ll toss in a thought rather than steal the floor from folks’ bird stories: most keepers I’ve seen do best picking one primary trait to anchor on (usually egg count or size, since those pay the bills) and then use the others as tie-breakers rather than trying to max everything at once — stacking too many selection pressures at once tends to slow progress on all of them. Temperament is worth weighting more than people expect too, since calm hens handle the stress of winter and breeding seasons better and tend to stay healthier.
For tracking, leg bands plus a simple log of hatch date, weight, and egg count per bird is the backbone — if you want it digital instead of a notebook, the Quail Keeper Max app (already unlocked with your community account) has fields for exactly that, so you can look back at “who laid what” come decision time instead of relying on memory.
Curious to hear what trait you’re leaning on this year, Ron — and who’s your keeper?
A note from one keeper to another: answers here reflect real quail-keeping experience shared in our community, not professional or veterinary advice. Every flock and setup is a little different — use your own judgment, and check with a vet for anything health-related.
Get answers like this for your covey
Quail Keeper Max keeps the full history of your flock — feed, eggs, health, hatches, and losses — in one place. Track it free, and on the Max plan you can ask Captain Coturnix, your covey advisor, questions about your own birds and get answers tailored to your records — not generic internet advice.
Start tracking free →Free plan for life · No credit card required · One account also joins the community
Got a quail question of your own?
The Quail Keeper Community is our forum for Coturnix keepers — ask anything, show off your flock, and get answers from people who raise quail every day. Anyone can browse free.
Join the community and automatically receive free access to Quail Keeper Max — one free account unlocks both.
See the full discussion →